26 prill 2010

Greek Tragedy Exposes Greek Mendacity

It seems as though Greeks will soon get the loan/bailout they've been looking to get from the IMF and the EU. Although few in the European Union are happy about this, it is worthwhile to note that this tragedy has also served to highlight the mendacity of the Greek government throughout the years. If you ask me, it all stems from a delusion of grandeur that modern Greek governments and the Greek Orthodox Church (and, to an extent, the people) have had about themselves. They still fancy themselves the same as their ancient forebears and demand the respect and regard worthy of the latter. As a result, the Greek machine has felt undeservingly entitled to the same advancements that the rest of Europe has achieved and has disingenuously portrayed itself as the economic and political equal to its European peers in order to obtain, first, EU membership and, secondly, the Euro.

At the same time, while touting once again their glorious past, and while exploiting their position in the EU they have become nothing short of a bully in Balkanic relations. They have set conditions (read, obstacles) for Albania's and Macedonia's membership in the EU and other European/North-Atlantic alliances, quoting as reason, in the case of Macedonia, a name, and complicating relations with Albania because of a Greek minority there of less than 3%, which has enjoyed special rights more than Albanians have ever dreamt of enjoying in Greece. It is of importance to note here that Greece is the only country in Europe (and perhaps in the world) that does not recognize religious or ethnic minorities within its territory.

Similarly, Greek governments have continuously been clutching to what they call The Great Idea, which consists of territorial pretensions in southern Albania. Greece has thus become a country with overt pretensions over another territory (and today, the Albanian nation) since its inception in 1829, and has recently become an insurmountable, unreasonable obstacle over a question of simple toponymy/onomastics, bringing the etymology of the word 'hypocrisy' closer to its meaning. At the same time, Greece has yet to invalidate its declaration of war on Albania since the latter was used as a platform by Mussolini to launch his attack on Greece. In other words, Greece is still at war with Albania and refuses to act to change that status.

I don't know if I am happy to see Greece where it is today. Behind a government's machinations lie the common people and I do not wish them any ills. I do, however, hope—for Greece's best and for the best of Balkanic and European relations—that this crisis, however tragic and taxing, will serve to set the current and future Greek governments along the path of better neighborly relations and more earnestness with themselves and their European counterparts.

[Yes, this is a rant.]

5 komente:

Olga Koulisis tha...

correction:
While Greece does not recognize ethnic minorities within its state, Greece does recognize certain religious minorities. The government admits the existence of a "Muslim" minority in Thrace (even though it really should be recognized as Turkish) as well as the existence of a Jewish minority throughout the state.

Btw, I've never seen the word Balkanic used...I could be wrong, but I think it's just Balkan.

Best,
Olga Koulisis

Trokashka tha...

I may stand corrected on the religious minorities, but it does not affect the general purpose of my rant.

And yes, I took the liberty of making up the word 'Balkanic.' My spellchecker didn't like it either. I just hate using 'Balkan' as an adjective.

Thank you for your input,

S

Rene C. Moya tha...

A rant, indeed.

I wouldn't argue with some of the sentiments you express here. The Greek dispute with Macedonia is particularly galling: territorial disputes, and lingering ethnonationalist tensions in the area make a fight over an appellation risible. The former tensions aren't particular to Greece, and I'd refrain from exaggerating the implications. But if 'Europe'--as a cultural and political concept--has any meaning whatsoever that meaning should be predicated, first and foremost, on the peaceful and equitable fraternity of its members, and a similar set of duties applies between members and obvious future members. Here, Greece has failed to fulfill its 'European calling'.

All that said, Greece's EU allies have no real choice but to bailout the debt-stricken country. Solidarity within an ostensible monetary union calls for as much--if for political reasons alone. Sure, Germany can allow a Greek implosion economically--but where would that leave EMU? And what of the wider European project?

I understand your frustrations, Sokrat: successive Greek governments have stonewalled on a variety of fronts, and it is not incumbent upon them to set their house in order. Perhaps, for all the suffering the Greek people will surely endure in the next few years under the IMF's austerity plans, something good can still come out of this.

René

Rene C. Moya tha...

I obviously mean the following:

'...it IS incumbent upon them to set their house in order...'

Hope you're well.

RCM

Unknown tha...

Greece also has stood in the way of Turkey's EU application. Cyprus has constituted a Greek puppet state ever since the Greeks initiated a coup during the reign of military dictator Papodopolous (quite possibly a miss-spelling), and this puppet state's antagonism toward Turkish Cyprus (another puppet state) has been used to hamper all of Turkey's EU ambitions. It's not so much the ethnic dispute that is so galling, but the fact that Greeks were so proud of their rejection in 2008 of the UN-backed Kofi Anan accord which sought to end the division of Cyprus which the Turkish side approved. The disagreement was over the number of representatives each side was to have in the federal government: the Turks, although a minority on the island, were given an almost equal number of representatives.

Now that Greece is thoroughly underwater, perhaps they will be a little more humble in their relations. There is actually talk of opening some of the Greek islands to Turkish tourists through a more painless visa program than the one that currently exists (for Turks, Greeks can come into TUrkey whenever they want without a visa, since they are part of Europe).

The fact is the Greek islanders love the business Turks bring to the islands, and indeed cannot survive without it. But their wishes go unheeded in Athens, where nationalism always takes precedent.

Chris